Home/Blog/Insights
All blog posts Insights, Digital Commerce

Merchant apps are outselling merchant websites, and the gap is widening

PYMNTS and Visa data shows merchant owned apps outperforming websites and physical stores. Push notifications, stored credentials, and controlled experiences are driving the shift.

Merchant apps are outselling merchant websites, and the gap is widening, CX Pay blog

Apps are winning on repeat purchases

The PYMNTS and Visa Digital Shopping Index tracks how consumers shop across 3 channels: merchant apps, merchant websites, and physical stores. The latest data shows merchant apps pulling ahead on conversion rate, average order value, and repeat purchase frequency. The gap has been growing for 4 consecutive quarters.

This is not about marketplaces like Amazon or MercadoLibre. This is about merchants who built their own apps, from restaurant chains to fashion retailers to hotel groups. Customers who download a merchant’s app spend more and come back more often than customers who visit the same merchant’s website.

Why apps convert better

3 things drive the difference.

Push notifications bring customers back. A website relies on the customer remembering to visit, or on paid ads to drive them there. An app sends a notification directly to the home screen. Open rates on push notifications run between 5% and 15%, compared to 1% to 2% for marketing emails. That is not a small difference when you are trying to fill rooms or tables on a slow Tuesday.

Stored payment credentials reduce friction. Once a customer saves their card in an app, every future purchase is 1 or 2 taps. Mobile browser checkout still requires more steps, even with autofill. Every additional step in a checkout flow costs conversion. Studies consistently put cart abandonment on mobile web above 80%, while in app checkout abandonment runs closer to 20%.

The experience is more controlled. A mobile browser introduces variables the merchant cannot manage: slow connections, pop up blockers, auto translate features that break checkout forms, cookie consent banners that obscure payment buttons. An app removes most of those variables.

The problem for mid sized merchants

Building and maintaining a native app costs real money. A basic commerce app with payment integration, push notifications, and inventory sync starts around $50,000 to $80,000 and carries ongoing costs for updates, app store compliance, and server infrastructure. For a mid sized hotel group or retail chain operating across a few Caribbean markets, that is a significant investment with uncertain return.

There is also an adoption challenge. Convincing customers to download an app requires marketing spend and a compelling reason to install it. A boutique hotel in Aruba or a restaurant group in Trinidad does not have the brand gravity to drive millions of downloads.

What closes the gap

Progressive web apps offer some of the benefits of native apps without the development cost. They load from a browser but can be added to the home screen, work offline, and send push notifications on most devices. They are not as fast or as capable as native apps, but they are dramatically cheaper to build and maintain.

Payment links and hosted checkout pages also help. A merchant can send a payment link through WhatsApp, embed it in an Instagram story, or place it inside any app experience without building custom payment infrastructure. The customer clicks, pays on a hosted page, and the transaction is done. It is not the same as a fully integrated app checkout, but it removes the friction of redirecting to a mobile website.

CX Pay’s payment links and hosted checkout work inside apps, messaging platforms, and browsers equally, so merchants can meet customers wherever they already are without rebuilding their payment stack for each channel.

The takeaway

Apps are winning because they reduce friction and increase return visits. Mid sized merchants who cannot build a native app should focus on the elements that make apps work, stored credentials, direct messaging, and simplified checkout, and find ways to replicate those through existing tools.

Explore payment links for your business Read more articles

Share
Previous Stablecoins settled $3.7 billion on card rails last year, and most merchants did not notice Next The CBCS has a 3 year plan, and payments modernization is at the centre of it